Cake Decorator of the Week

Forum: Site Feedback

I may get stoned and harrased for posting this but I feel it needs to be said.

I always saw the cake decorator of the week as a way to pay homage to the very talented people on this site and also to display talents of those hidden treasures. Let me say that I feel all those who have gotten cake decorator of the week was well deserved.

My problem is that there are over 10,000 decorators on here and there have been 8 repeats (in the 9 months the Gazette has been published and it is trackable). One decorator was even featured 3 times in that time frame.

I feel that the cake decorator of the week is losing its flair. It seems as if it is more a popularity contest than a true way to feature some awesome talent.

I have said my peace so now I will get off my soapbox and wait for the stoning.



14 0
Share Tweet

14 Replies

Cakery Creation Liz Huber ...

Hi Jennifer, No stoning from me. I’m pretty sure you are not alone in feeling this way. You get mad love from me and I love your work(this is why I ‘follow’ you on here)!

Prima Cakes and Cookies - Jennifer ...

Thank CakeryCreation…. I think you work is pretty awesome too :)

Benni Rienzo Radic ...

I have noticed also that there have been repeats as well. I guess maybe a question would be what are the determining factors that go in choosing decorator of the week on a weekly basis.

Susana ...

The only thing i can say is all the chosen cakes r gorgeous,for one reason or another.Maybe will be much better if was more than one each week because r many awesome cakes in here!

Jenniffer White ...

I thought I had seen some repeats, but I convinced myself it was all in my head. Glad to know I’m not as crazy as I thought I was!

June ("Clarky's Cakes") ...

I have to agree with you cupadeecakes. I also thought there were repeats…. glad I wasn’t crazy as well. I know for sure the cake artist now featured, although very talented, not taking that away, definitely has been featured before.
With the plethora of pro & non-pro cake artists here, you could feature a new one every week and never run out of talented decorators.

Fleur de Sucre ...

I agree. Measuring by popularity is very easy and democratic. But doesn’t equal ‘by talent’.
How do you want to measure talent? Guess it calls for a board of ’Pro’s’, mixed by different geographical origins. I see a great difference in taste and style by country… These pros would then vote for a talent, but that costs time and needs committment…

Any other ideas?

Prima Cakes and Cookies - Jennifer ...

See I think there is already enough competition on the site with the daily Top 3 and 15. Decorator of the Week should just be a random person selected to feature there artwork. This way we all get to see someone we may not have noticed before.

Why does everything have to be about popularity???

Sugarpixy ...

No stoning here on Cakesdecor. That is why I love this site. Everyone is friendly and supportive! Keep your chin up ,as long as your customers and or family and friends are happy with your work you should be happy too.xx

Prima Cakes and Cookies - Jennifer ...

Lori-Ann thank you for your support but I wasn’t writing this topic because I didn’t get picked. It just seemed to dilute the purpose of the showcasing to me when the same people are picked over and over.

Amanda’s Little Cake Boutique ...

I remember seeing somewhere that the decorator of the week was based upon the amount of activity that member shows – comments on others pictures, helpfulness on the forums, activity on their own pictures etc.

So I guess if it is worked out by a computer, then it will happen that some people will get picked over and over.

Not saying that these people don’t deserve to be the decorator of the week, as everyone so far I have seen is absolutely awesome!

Amanda x

Michal Bulla ...

Hi all,

as I said in one of my blog entries before, we are always making some tweaks to the formulas that are behind Daily Top Cakes and Decorator Of The Week to achieve selecting the best of the best posted here on CakesDecor. We adjusted the Cake Decorator of the Week formula recently which should result in less repeats throughout the year.

Anyway, thank you for your suggestions.

Prima Cakes and Cookies - Jennifer ...

Thank you for the clarification. I didn’t realize that the Decorator of the Week was a formula also. I knew that Daily Top Cakes was. I must have missed that blog post.


Xclusive ...

I have been following this interesting post and the discussions it generated. I admire the courage, openess, tactfulness that has been displayed by each individual. Above all, the love and support shown is highly commendable. For me, that is the whole essence of this platform called cakes decor.