Hi, I don’t know if you would mind the taste, but it might help to add a bit of dutched cocoa powder, which has a rich red tint to it. Not to turn the buttercream brown, but help darken it and turn it from pink to red.
Americolor super red tastes quite bitter in my opinion… but maybe I’m just sensitive!
Xuân-Minh, Minh Cakes || http://www.minhcakes.ch/en || http://www.facebook.com/minhcakes.ch