I have the same dilemma. I am TOLD that Americolor Super Red is pretty good and LESS bitter, so I bought it but did not try it yet. Oh, and Wilton NO TASTE RED does have a taste. :( I was also told that possibly POWDERED color adds no taste.
xx
Sharon
Sharon A. *** Not Your Average Cupcake! https://www.facebook.com/Notyouraveragecupcake